- Günther Klee
- 30.10.2023
- Websites
Request a free guide: Which e-commerce platform is right for me?
Table of contents
We present five e-commerce platforms that are an interesting alternative to Shopify. Each of these platforms has certain strengths, which is why they are particularly suitable for certain business models and corporate structures.
Umbraco Commerce vs. Shopify
Advantages of Umbraco Commerce
Umbraco Commerce is based on the open-source content management system Umbraco and therefore offers a high level of flexibility when creating an online shop. Unlike Shopify, the operator has full control over design and functionality and can customize them to specific requirements. Since the Umbraco source code is freely available, in-house developers or specialized Umbraco partners can make customizations. This allows for deep integration into existing systems. Umbraco Commerce does not charge transaction fees and offers numerous extensions that enable shop operators to add functions such as shipping, marketing, and accounting. The extensive product management supports the creation of product variants, categories, and the entry of detailed product data. Since Umbraco Commerce is based on the established Umbraco CMS, there are effective SEO tools for optimizing the visibility of the web shop in search engines.
Disadvantages of Umbraco Commerce
Umbraco Commerce requires advanced technical knowledge to implement, customize and maintain the platform. Setting up an Umbraco Commerce store is more time-consumingthan with out-of-the-box solutions such as Shopify. In the DACH region, the CMS is also less well known and has a relatively small market share compared to some other e-commerce platforms.
Shopware vs. Shopify
Advantages of Shopware
Shopware is an open-source platform: the extensive customization options for the front and back end allow seamless integration into existing platforms. Comprehensive internationalization and multilingual features make Shopware a good option for companies operating in different countries and languages. In addition, Shopware has a powerful product management system for creating and managing complex product structures and variants.
Integrated SEO tools make it easier to increase the visibility of the web shop. It also offers content marketing and blogging features that make it easier to create content for websites. Shopware is also well-suited for B2B companies: it includes B2B-specific features such as individual pricing for business customers and budget management.
Disadvantages of Shopware
Shopware can be complex for ecommerce beginners and requires a higher level of technical knowledge than Shopify. Setting up and configuring it also requires more time and technical skills. Shopware is an open-source solution, but the costs for extensions, customizations and hosting options can be significant. Although Shopware has its own marketplace for extensions, it offers a relatively limited selection of available apps and extensions compared to Shopify or even WooCommerce.
Free alternative: WooCommerce vs. Shopify
Advantages of WooCommerce
WooCommerce is an open-source extension for the popular content management system WordPress. It is therefore an interesting option for users or companies familiar with WordPress. Those with the necessary technical expertise can adapt the source codeto meet almost any design and functionality requirement. WooCommerce WooCommerce does not charge transaction fees and the operator is free to choose an independent payment processor. WooCommerce itself is free, but often additional plugins and extensions are needed to fulfill all requirements – these are not free of charge. The advantage is that the functions of the online shop can be expanded by such extensions even without programming knowledge. For example, it is possible to integrate various marketing tools, shipping options, accounting software, etc. When managing products with different variants (e.g., size, color or style), WooCommerce imposes hardly any restrictions on the shop operator. Since the platform is based on WordPress, it can also draw on numerous plugins for SEO optimization. The choice of hosting provider and domain for the shop is free, so resources and performance can be customized to the requirements of the shop.
Disadvantages of WooCommerce
To fully utilize WooCommerce, technical knowledge in areas such as website development, hosting and server administration is required. The website operator is responsible for the security and maintenance of the web shop. This means that security and software updates must be conducted regularly and independently. WooCommerce is also not designed for very high traffic: for web shops with a large product catalog or many visitors, WooCommerce's performance can be impaired, especially if there is no powerful hosting infrastructure available. High-quality support and documentation are sometimes difficult to obtain, which makes it difficult to solve problems efficiently and learn best practices.
BigCommerce vs. Shopify
Advantages of BigCommerce
BigCommerce offers a wide range of integrated features, including product management, marketing tools, reporting, analytics, and extensive shipping and payment options. For companies with very extensive product catalogs, BigCommerce is a strong alternative due to the many product variations and options. It is not open-source software, but it can be customized to a certain extent. The standard supports sales in different countries and offers functions for multilingualism and currency conversion. BigCommerce features functions that are specifically geared towards B2B commerce, including individual pricing for large customers (or the creation of customer groups) and extensive inventory management.
Disadvantages of BigCommerce
Although BigCommerce offers a range of price plans, it is often more expensive than comparable e-commerce solutions. Transaction fees also have an impact on the overall costs over time. While it is possible to customize the design, the flexibility compared to open-source platforms such as Umbraco Commerce is limited in terms of customization options. There is a limited selection of (free) themes, but further customization requires advanced HTML/CSS knowledge. In terms of search engine optimization and the management of metadata and URLs, the platform is less flexible than other solutions.
Request a guide: Which e-commerce platform is right for me?
Sitecore OrderCloud vs. Shopify
Advantages of Sitecore OrderCloud
Sitecore OrderCloud is designed to meet the needs of large and complex organizations. It offers comprehensive solutions for B2B and B2C e-commerce as well as for the distribution of digital and physical products. The platform is highly customizable and enables companies to implement complex e-commerce requirements and workflows and can be freely designed according to brand guidelines. Like Sitecore's CMS, OrderCloud follows the headless approach, which makes it possible to separate the front-end and back-end parts of the e-commerce system. This offers moreflexibility in designing and integration of different customer touchpoints. For B2B commerce, the platform offers extensive functionality: individual pricing, offer management, order processing and user management for large customers are important examples. A special feature is the digital asset management, which also enables the sale of digital products. Robust APIs allow the connection and integration of third-party services, back-office systems, and external tools.
Disadvantages of Sitecore OrderCloud
Sitecore OrderCloud has a certain complexitydue to its extensive functionality and adaptability. Setting up and configuring the platform requires techincal expertise and experience. Since it is an enterprise platform, OrderCloud is relatively expensive. The learning curve for users is steep, so training should be planned and a longer training period for new employees should be expected.
Conclusion: What is the best Shopify alternative?
The e-commerce platforms listed above offer advantages over Shopify in terms of flexibility and adaptability – both in terms of design and functionality. Shopify is an out-of-the-box solution, while these alternatives are aimed at creating a customizes web shop. Standard solutions quickly reach their limits, especially in the area of B2B web shops, when it comes to mapping complex products and product variations. In addition, an international presence of the e-commerce company speaks in favor of a solution that can meet the resulting complexity of the business model. Many companies reach a point in a growth phase where one-size-fits-all offers such as Shopify can no longer meet the increasing demands. Of course, the best alternative for a company always depends on its particularities. Based on Cyber-Solutions' experience as a digitalization partner, Umbraco Commerce is often an excellent solution for medium-sized companies in the B2B and B2C sectors. International corporations, on the other hand, are well advised to use Sitecore OrderCloud, as it can also manage very high levels of complexity.
Let's work together to determine which e-commerce platform is right for you!
Do you have any questions?
Please do not hesitate to contact us. Our team is happy to help you with any questions you may have.